Why You Should Never Quote a Price in the First Email (and What to Send Instead)

“A booking inquiry just landed in your inbox. The very first line says: "Hi— how much do you charge?"

If you fire back with a number right now, one of two things happens. You lose the gig. Or you book it for less than it's worth.

 
There's a better way. And the magician pricing email I'm about to walk you through takes about 90 seconds to write.

 
Most magicians treat that first email like a vending machine. Money in, price out. That trains the client to compare you on dollars instead of value. It's why your fee gets pushback every single time.

 
Here's the shift: don't quote in the first reply. Send what I call the First-Date Reply instead.

 
You don't propose marriage on a first date. You don't quote a price on a first email either. The First-Date Reply is short. It builds value, asks a few smart questions, and earns the right to quote a higher fee later— without sounding pushy.

 
Magicians who use this approach quote 20% higher and book it without flinching.

 
How to handle the price question in a booking inquiry

 
The First-Date Reply has four parts. Each one does a specific job.

Part 1: Treat them like a person, not a transaction

 
Start with one sentence that thanks them and shows you actually read their note.

 
Something like: "Thanks for reaching out about your event on August 14th— sounds like a fun one."

 
That's it. One sentence.

 
Most magicians skip this and dive straight into logistics. You've already stood out, and you haven't even gotten to the good part yet.

 
Part 2: Ask three questions that prove you take their event seriously

 
This is where the magic (sorry) happens. Every question you ask signals expertise. It tells the buyer you think about the event, not just the trick.

 
Pick three from this list:

 
• How many guests are you expecting?
• What's the age range?
• What does the venue look like— indoor, outdoor, room layout?
• What's happening right before and right after my show?
• What problem are you trying to solve with this performer?

 
That last one is gold. Most clients have never been asked it. When you ask, they feel seen.

 
Part 3: Show what you bring (without bragging)

 
Now drop in one or two short lines about how easy you make it.

 
Mine usually look like this: "Just so you know— I bring my own PA and microphone. I'm fully self-contained. Point me to the performing area and I'm set."

 
Or: "I also carry a $1 million liability policy and a satisfaction guarantee."

 
You're not bragging. You're removing hidden fears before the client has to voice them:

 
• Will this person actually show up?
• Are there hidden costs?
• What happens if it goes wrong?

 
You answered all three without them having to ask.

 
Part 4: Soft close — promise the price, don't quote it yet

End with one line that keeps the conversation alive.

 
"Once I know a bit more about your event, I'll put together pricing tailored to what you actually need."

 
You haven't quoted. You haven't dodged. You've taken control of the next step.

 
What top magicians send instead of a price quote

A few years back, I commented on a magic-business newsletter I liked. I sent maybe two sentences. "Great article! Loved the part about pricing."

 
The reply blew me away. Not in a good way.

 
The author's assistant emailed me back with a list of mentorship packages. Most were $3,000 or more. They didn't know my goals.

 They didn't know where I was in my career. They didn't even know what I needed.

 
They went from first date straight to "let's get married."

 
That's the pitch-slap. And clients feel it the same way you and I do. Aggressive. Tone-deaf. A little insulting.

 
Now flip it.

 
When I get a school inquiry, I usually know the price the second I hear "K-5, two assemblies, one hour each." I've been doing this 20-plus years. I could quote in five seconds and move on.

 
But I don't.

 
I ask my questions anyway. I ask about the kids. I ask about the venue. I mention my PA system and my guarantee.

 
Why? Because by the time we get to the price, the buyer feels like a person— not a wallet. The price stops being the only thing in the room. The relationship is in the room too. And the relationship is what books the gig at the higher fee.

 
The mistake to avoid

 
There's a fake-humble version of this that doesn't work.

 
It's the magician who replies, "Well, it depends on a lot of factors!" and stops there.

 
That's not a First-Date Reply. That's a dodge. The client reads it and thinks, "Okay, this person didn't answer my question and didn't help me either." Delete.

 
The First-Date Reply gives them something. Your questions. Your professionalism. Your guarantee. It's value-loaded before it asks for a single thing in return.

 
That's the whole difference. And it's the difference between knowing what to say when a client asks how much and just stalling for time.

 
Do this in the next 7 days

 
Three steps. They take maybe 20 minutes total.

 
1. Save a First-Date Reply template in your email drafts. Use the four parts above. Pick your three favorite questions. Write your one line about what you bring.

 
2. The next inquiry that asks "how much?", use the template. Don't quote. Send the questions instead.

 
3. When you finally do quote, quote 10 to 20% higher than usual. Say it out loud first. If your voice cracks on the number, practice until it doesn't. Buyers can hear doubt. They can read it in your email too.

 
The bottom line

 
The first email isn't really asking for a price.

 
It's asking whether you're worth talking to.

 
Answer that question first. The price almost always takes care of itself.

Want to be the magician clients expect to pay top dollar?

 
The First-Date Reply changes how a single inquiry plays out. But there's a deeper game underneath it.

 
When you're positioned the right way in your market, clients don't just agree to your higher fee. They expect it. They walk into the conversation already prepared to pay more than they'd pay any other magician in your area.

 
I put that whole positioning strategy into a free guide. It's called The 2-Word Secret to Eliminate Your Competition & Become Your Area's Highest-Paid Magician. Almost no magicians use it. And the ones who do don't use it correctly.

 
Grab it free here: https://theprofessionalmagicianclubpro.com/free-pdf-offer/

To find out more how I can help you book more shows at higher fees, click the button below to see my list of services.

© Copyright Cris Johnson, Inc.