“It’s basically just my online business card.”
I’ve heard some version of that more times than I can count.
And it’s always said like it’s a good thing. Like it’s modesty.
Back in 2021 I sat down and went through more than 200 magicians’ websites.
Not casually, either. I actually worked through them, one after another, because I wanted to know whether there was any real market for what I do — building sites and writing the words that go on them.
There was. Good grief, there was.
Most of them looked like they’d been cobbled together by somebody with no sense of design at all. The rest looked fine and read so badly I was genuinely amazed the guy was getting any work.
But that wasn’t the real problem.
The real problem was sitting underneath almost every single one of them, and it’s that sentence up at the top of this email.
They all believed the site was a business card.
Here’s what a business card does.
Nothing.
It sits in a drawer. It waits. Somebody has to already know you, already like you, and already be hunting for you before that little rectangle does one useful thing in its whole life.
And if that’s what you think your website is, you’ll build it exactly that way. Your name. Your logo. A few photos. A list of everything you do. Contact info way down at the bottom.
An “About Me.”
Then you’ll wonder why the thing never rings.
Your website is not a card. It’s an employee.
It’s the only employee you will ever have who works 24 hours a day, seven days a week, 365 days a year. Never calls in sick. Never has an off night. Never asks for a raise.
The only real question is whether you’ve given that employee anything to say.
The tell is easy to spot, by the way.
A business-card site is about you. A salesperson site is about them.
And “them” isn’t one person. The PTO mom trying to fill an assembly slot in October and the corporate planner with a budget and a hotel ballroom are not the same human being. They do not want to read the same page.
This is the “magic for all occasions” trap with a web address attached.
Anybody who tells you they’ve got one all-purpose show that fits every market is only deluding themselves. Same goes for the site. Talk to everybody and you talk to nobody.
Now, I can already hear somebody over on The Magic Cafe warming up. “What about Facebook? Instagram? I get plenty of work from…”
Stop.
When you run your business on somebody else’s platform, you play by their rules. And they move the goalposts whenever it suits them. Reach gets throttled. Accounts get nuked for no reason anybody will explain to you. And the fix is always the same — pay more.
You’re renting. You don’t own a thing.
Let me tell you about my own site, because it is not impressive.
My photos aren’t studio shots. They’re grab shots from real shows, and honestly, I think that helps me. They look like the real world because they are the real world.
But here’s what happens anyway.
By the time a school actually calls me, they’ve already read it. They know what the show is. They know why it’s the right one for their building.
The prospect is half sold before I say a single word.
That’s not design doing that. That’s the site doing its job.
And a site that does its job needs three things.
You have to genuinely understand the market you’re selling to. The words have to do the actual selling. And it has to look like a professional put it together.
Most magicians start with the third one. Pick a template, pick a font, pick a color that feels magical. Then they skip the first two entirely and can’t figure out why a nice-looking site doesn’t book anything.
Nice-looking isn’t the job. Booking is the job.
So here’s your homework this week, and it costs you nothing.
Pull up your own site on your phone. Not your laptop — your phone. That’s where your buyers are standing when they find you.
Look at the first screen only. Before anybody scrolls.
Can a total stranger tell, in about four seconds, what you do, who it’s for, and what to do next?
Then count your I’s. Then count your you’s.
If the I’s are winning, you’re not running a salesperson. You’re holding a business card.
A few years back I wrote some website copy for a client, and when I handed it over he said something that redirected my whole business. He said, “I want you to build the site. I trust you to bring your words to life on it.”
I’d built my own sites. Never anybody else’s. So I went digging through videos, and most of them were busy teaching me how to run an e-commerce empire when all I wanted was a clean site that books shows.
So eventually I just built the training I couldn’t find. It’s the magician’s website builder — the market thinking, the words, and the actual build, with no coding and no expensive software.
But do the phone test first. That part’s free, and it’ll tell you more in four seconds than I can in a thousand words.
Have a great week!
